Montana Historical Society

Big Sky. Big Land. Big History.

Montana: Stories of the Land

Companion Website and Online Teacher's Guide

Chapter 7 - Two Worlds Collide, 1850-1887


Learning From Historical Documents


Letter from Frank Elliott to "Father," from the Madison Valley, May 1865. Francis "Frank" Elliott Papers, 1866-1881. Small Collection 660. Montana Historical Society Research Center. Archives. Excerpted in Not In Precious Metals Alone: A Manuscript History of Montana (Helena, 1976): 57.


Context for Frank Elliott's Letter:

Many settlers believed in Manifest Destiny-America's unique obligation to expand civilization across the continent. Many also assumed that because Indian people did not construct permanent buildings, the Indians were not really using the land. Finally, many settlers also held exaggerated fears about the American Indians around them. These attitudes combined to create righteous anger and aggressive posturing whenever conflict between Indians and settlers was even suspected. Frank Elliott, an Irish immigrant who joined the gold rush, displayed an unfortunate, but common attitude when he asserted that "there is but one way to treat [Indians] and that is extermination." Interestingly, many historians now believe that John Bozeman-whose death triggered Elliott's outrage-was not killed by Indians but rather by his partner, Tom Cover.


About Primary Sources:

Letters, diary entries, census records, newspapers, and photographs are all examples of "primary sources," material created at a particular moment in the past that has survived into the present. Primary sources can provide clues to the past. They are our windows into an earlier time. The Montana Historical Society contains thousands of primary sources. In the 1970s, archivists collected just a few snippets into a book, which they called Not in Precious Metals Alone: A Manuscript History of Montana. That book is now on the web in its entirety. The above sample from that book relates directly to this chapter.


Gatling Gun
Gatling gun battery, Fort Lincoln, D. T., June 1877, photo by F. Jay Haynes, Montana Historical Society Photo Archives Haynes Foundation Coll. H-61
Red Cloud
Red Cloud, Montana Historical Society Photo Archives 954-795